I recently read an article called "Your cellphone isn't give you cancer, largest study assure" by Maria Cheng on msnbc.com. The articles claim was "Danish researchers can offer some reassurance if you're concerned about your cellphone: Don't worry. Your device is probably safe." This was noted at the very beginning of the article so you knew exactly what the author wanted to talk about. The rest of the article was spent giving substantial information and quotes in order to back up their claim. Their evidence was also from respectable and well known organizations such as Food and Drug Administration, Federal Communications Commission, and the Danish Strategic Research council. The direct quotes used were from people who truly understood the study and the findings, it was not just some random person found on the street. For example, "'Our study provides little evidence for a causal association, but we cannot rule out a small to moderate increase in risk for subgroups of heavy user," said Patrizia Frei, of the Institute of Cancer Epidemiology in Copenhagen, Denmark, one of the paper's authors." In this article, the evidence leads me to believe the claim. This is because the article uses sources that represent high quality. Also, the study had so many participants that it backs up the evidence by sheer numbers.
In using Toulmin's Model it helps me to better understand whether claims are better or more poorly supported. Hopefully I will begin to use this in my daily life to double check whether the information I am gathering from the web, a book or a news station is true and I challenge all of you to do the same. We want to continue in learning how to decipher whether or not information can be trusted.
-Lauren Haas
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/44982462/ns/health-cancer/
If evidence from the Danish Strategic Research council is used to support the claim that cell phones don't cause cancer, what assumption is Cheng making about her readers and their values?
ReplyDeleteI thought you had a good analysis with all the quoting and such, but i didn't say anything about the authors warrant or anything like that. Your claim and your evidence is good though.
ReplyDeleteI also got a little lost on what the claim was, but overall good post. I remember it being a pretty big scare when cell phones started booming and everyone thought they caused cancer.. Very interesting.
ReplyDelete